Looks and feels like a good jacket, but the fit is not great, I am tall and have to go up a size to get the sleeve and body length, which makes the rest of the top pretty loose fitting. It is also definitely a mid layer on cold days, you really notice the non windproof material when you turn your back to the wind or if the wind is blowing side on. I feel like the arms should be completely made from the windproof material and that it should wrap a bit more around the torso. In hindsight, I should have bought the freezing point jacket.